Difference between revisions of "Arakawa Nagazane"

From SamuraiWiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
m
m (added sources)
 
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 2: Line 2:
  
  
Arakawa was [[Uesugi Kenshin|Uesugi Kenshin's]] ''[[Kagemusha]]'' (double) during the 4th battle of Kawanakajima.  During the battle, [[Takeda Shingen]] and Kenshin purportedly fought in one-on-one combat, however, there is a evidence that the man who attacked Takeda Shingen was not, in fact, Uesugi Kenshin at all, but his Kagemusha, Arakawa Izu no Kami. According to the ''[[Kenshin Nenpu]]'' (Kenshin Chronological Record), Arakawa, who was dressed as Kenshin, rode at Shingen and attacked. Shingen was unable to draw his sword, and so blocked with his war fan.  [[Hara Osumi no Kami|Hara Ôsumi no Kami]] ran to Shingen's aid, and drove off the mounted warrior.
+
Arakawa was [[Uesugi Kenshin|Uesugi Kenshin's]] ''[[Kagemusha]]'' (double) during the [[Fourth Battle of Kawanakajima]].  During the battle, [[Takeda Shingen]] and Kenshin purportedly fought in one-on-one combat, however, there is a evidence that the man who attacked Takeda Shingen was not, in fact, Uesugi Kenshin at all, but his Kagemusha, Arakawa Izu no Kami. According to the ''[[Kenshin Nenpu]]'' (Kenshin Chronological Record), Arakawa, who was dressed as Kenshin, rode at Shingen and attacked. Shingen was unable to draw his sword, and so blocked with his war fan.  [[Hara Osumi no Kami|Hara Ôsumi no Kami]] ran to Shingen's aid, and drove off the mounted warrior.
  
 
To further confuse the issue, according to the [[Hokuetsu Gunki]], at a later date after the battle, Shingen recieved a visit from a monk by the name of [[Tenkai]] who would later become an advisor to [[Tokugawa Ieyasu]]. Tenkai would tell Ieyasu that Shingen told him during thier meeting that "the man who crossed swords with Kenshin that day was not me, but someone who looked like me". Meaning that apparently it wasn't Shingen but ''his'' Kagemusha that fought off the attack.
 
To further confuse the issue, according to the [[Hokuetsu Gunki]], at a later date after the battle, Shingen recieved a visit from a monk by the name of [[Tenkai]] who would later become an advisor to [[Tokugawa Ieyasu]]. Tenkai would tell Ieyasu that Shingen told him during thier meeting that "the man who crossed swords with Kenshin that day was not me, but someone who looked like me". Meaning that apparently it wasn't Shingen but ''his'' Kagemusha that fought off the attack.
  
 
Although the [[Koyo Gunkan]] states that it was combat between Shingen and Kenshin, there is little evidence to support this. The issue is further complicated by the fact that Shingen and Kenshin had never met face to face, and therefore did not know what the other looked like. So it is possible that the "famous" clash between Shingen and Kenshin during the 4th battle of Kawanakajima was in fact a clash between thier respective Kagemusha instead.
 
Although the [[Koyo Gunkan]] states that it was combat between Shingen and Kenshin, there is little evidence to support this. The issue is further complicated by the fact that Shingen and Kenshin had never met face to face, and therefore did not know what the other looked like. So it is possible that the "famous" clash between Shingen and Kenshin during the 4th battle of Kawanakajima was in fact a clash between thier respective Kagemusha instead.
 +
==References==
 +
* Sato, Hiroaki ''[[Legends of the Samurai]]''
 +
* Narumoto, Tatsuya. ''Sengoku Bushou Omoshiro Jiten'', Japan, 1998
  
 
[[Category:Samurai]][[Category:Sengoku Period]]
 
[[Category:Samurai]][[Category:Sengoku Period]]

Latest revision as of 18:09, 15 November 2006

  • Title: Izu no Kami


Arakawa was Uesugi Kenshin's Kagemusha (double) during the Fourth Battle of Kawanakajima. During the battle, Takeda Shingen and Kenshin purportedly fought in one-on-one combat, however, there is a evidence that the man who attacked Takeda Shingen was not, in fact, Uesugi Kenshin at all, but his Kagemusha, Arakawa Izu no Kami. According to the Kenshin Nenpu (Kenshin Chronological Record), Arakawa, who was dressed as Kenshin, rode at Shingen and attacked. Shingen was unable to draw his sword, and so blocked with his war fan. Hara Ôsumi no Kami ran to Shingen's aid, and drove off the mounted warrior.

To further confuse the issue, according to the Hokuetsu Gunki, at a later date after the battle, Shingen recieved a visit from a monk by the name of Tenkai who would later become an advisor to Tokugawa Ieyasu. Tenkai would tell Ieyasu that Shingen told him during thier meeting that "the man who crossed swords with Kenshin that day was not me, but someone who looked like me". Meaning that apparently it wasn't Shingen but his Kagemusha that fought off the attack.

Although the Koyo Gunkan states that it was combat between Shingen and Kenshin, there is little evidence to support this. The issue is further complicated by the fact that Shingen and Kenshin had never met face to face, and therefore did not know what the other looked like. So it is possible that the "famous" clash between Shingen and Kenshin during the 4th battle of Kawanakajima was in fact a clash between thier respective Kagemusha instead.

References